Good Quiet vs Bad Quiet


Hi Reader,

“Quiet” has earned a bad rap.

Mostly because many of us have used it as a weapon.

“Rather than address the critical comment you just made, I’ll punish you for making it by quietly withdrawing. I’ll lash back at you through silent avoidance, by shutting you out.”

Sadly, that was my M.O.

I heard Andrew J. Bauman — author and mental health counselor — say, “Avoidance is violence.”

If it’s easier to remember:

Silence is violence.

So yes, quiet has a dark side.

But sometimes quiet is necessary in a marriage. While most women process out loud — by talking, many of us XY-chromosome types process in silence — by thinking.

Here’s why that can be problematic:

Quiet avoidance — the violent kind — sounds the same to your wife’s ears as quiet reflection — the thoughtful kind.

She can’t tell the difference!

Until now.

This little script will change your marriage:

I haven’t shut you out. I haven’t gone anywhere. I am quiet, but it’s because I’m processing what you’ve said. It’s the good quiet, not the bad quiet.

Strong.

Clear.

Thoughtful.

Reassuring.

Say it (or text it) after a heated exchange and your wife gets to relax into your masculine energy. She gets to drop her defenses. She gets to change her story from this ...

There he goes! Running off again! Shutting me out again! He obviously didn’t like something I said. Or maybe I didn‘t say it just right and little baby had his feelings hurt. As usual, it‘s allllllllll about him. It’s never about about me or my pain. How I’m feeling. What I need more of. Nope! Just him. I swear, the man is incapable of intimacy.

“And I know what’s coming next ... Three days of hell to pay. Three days of the silent treatment. Three days of me feeling abandoned and alone while I paste a smile on my face for the kids. I don’t know why I bother. This marriage is so toxic.”

To this ...

“Wow. That’s a breath of fresh air! My husband listening. My husband communicating. Thinking about me. Caring about me. Not punishing me. Not stonewalling me. I like this version of him. You know, I probably came off a little harsh back there. I need to get better at telling him what I want without laying into him. Without being so critical. That’s something for me to work on.”

You’ve moved your marriage out of momentary crisis ... into heal, mend, and repair mode.

Quietly.

Powerfully.

Magnetically.

Put It to Work

  1. Memorize our little script: “I haven’t shut you out. I haven’t gone anywhere. I am quiet, but it’s because I’m processing what you’ve said. It’s the good quiet, not the bad quiet.”
  2. Use it often.


Your Coach,

Hi, I'm Jeff.

I help husbands grow and become great men. The kind their wives swoon over. Join the one percent! New content delivered weekly.

Read more from Hi, I'm Jeff.

Hi Reader, This week’s small-but-mighty email opens with J.R.R. Tolkien on being overlooked: Deeds will not be less valiant because they’re unpraised. (Aragorn, The Return of the King) Husband and fellow warrior-king, Keep doing the right thing because it’s the right thing. Keep doing the right thing because that’s the kind of man you are. Put a knife to the throat of neediness. Needing your wife to notice, thank, or praise you for your benevolent deed. Otherwise, your good deed turns rancid...

Hi Reader, Last week, one of the men in my private community (we’ll call him Dan) shared a story that will dramatically improve your marriage. Here’s what happened … Dan is chillin’ with his family when his cell phone rings. It’s their next-door neighbor. During the course of the phone call, Dan is gracious, kind, patient, and attentive. Like he’s filming a telephone etiquette video for Dale Carnegie’s How to Win Friends and Influence People. The call ends and Dan’s wife — stunned by the...

Hi Reader, When you think of your marriage, it’s unlikely your mind goes to the second law of thermodynamics (or law of entropy), but it needs to. Otherwise, you risk losing the people you love most. In physics, the law of entropy says that all systems, left unattended, will run down. Unless new energy is pumped in, the organism will disintegrate. Entropy is at work in many areas other than physics. I see it, for instance, when I work with couples whose marriages are in trouble. A marriage...